Medicare Advantage vs. Original Medicare With Medigap: How to Compare Your Total Yearly Cost
Linda and Raymond Brooks, both 67, sat at their kitchen table in Columbus, Ohio, with two Medicare mailers and a calculator. One flyer advertised a Medicare Advantage plan with a $0 monthly premium, dental cleanings, and a gym benefit. The other was a quote for a Medigap policy that would cost each of them a few hundred dollars a month on top of the Part B premium. On paper the Advantage plan looked like it saved them several thousand dollars a year. What the flyers did not show was what each choice would cost in a year when one of them needed surgery, a hospital stay, and months of follow-up visits.
That is the real comparison: not the premium, but the total cost of a year, in a quiet year and in a bad one. Medicare Open Enrollment runs from October 15 to December 7, 2026, and any change you make takes effect January 1, 2027. This guide shows how to put both paths on the same worksheet so you can see the full range of what you might pay. It is general information based on Medicare.gov and CMS publications, not personal insurance advice.
Two different ways to buy the same basic coverage
Original Medicare is Part A for hospital care and Part B for doctor and outpatient care, run by the federal government. You can see any doctor or hospital in the U.S. that accepts Medicare, and in most cases you do not need a referral or approval in advance. For Part B services you usually pay 20% of the Medicare-approved amount after the deductible, and there is no yearly limit on what you pay. That open-ended 20% is why many people add a Medigap policy, sold by private insurers, plus a separate Part D drug plan.
Medicare Advantage, also called Part C, is offered by private companies approved by Medicare. These plans bundle Part A, Part B, and usually Part D into one card. In exchange, you may need to use the plan's network, and you may need approval, called prior authorization, before certain services or drugs are covered. Every plan sets a yearly limit on what you pay for covered Part A and Part B services.
So the trade is roughly this: Original Medicare with Medigap tends to cost more every month but less in a bad year, while Medicare Advantage tends to cost less every month but leaves more exposure when you use a lot of care. The worksheet below shows how big that gap is for your situation.
The worksheet: four lines for each path
To compare honestly, write down the same four lines for each option.
Line 1 is premiums you will pay no matter what. On both paths you pay the Part B premium. CMS had not announced the 2027 Part B premium or deductible as of November 9, 2026, and the 2027 Medicare and You handbook still lists the 2026 figures, so use 2026 numbers for now: a standard premium of $202.90 a month and a $283 annual deductible. Add the Medigap premium and the Part D premium for the Original Medicare path, or the plan premium, if any, for the Advantage path.
Line 2 is a quiet year. Estimate what you would pay out of pocket for routine visits, lab work, and your current prescriptions.
Line 3 is a bad year. On the Advantage path, this is the plan's in-network out-of-pocket maximum plus drug costs. On the Medigap path, it depends on the plan letter you buy, plus drug costs.
Line 4 is the things money does not capture: whether your doctors are in network, how often you travel, and how much prior authorization would bother you.
Where the out-of-pocket ceilings sit for 2027
For 2027, CMS caps how high a Medicare Advantage plan can set its in-network out-of-pocket maximum. Under the final CMS memo for contract year 2027, the highest allowed in-network limit is $9,850. Preferred provider organization plans, which cover some out-of-network care, can have a combined in-network and out-of-network limit of up to $14,800. Many plans choose lower limits, and the limit does not include Part D drug costs or most extra benefits.
Prescription drugs have their own ceiling on both paths. In 2027, out-of-pocket costs for covered Part D drugs are capped at $2,400, and a plan's drug deductible can be no more than $700, according to the 2027 Medicare and You handbook. That cap applies whether your drug coverage comes from a stand-alone Part D plan or from an Advantage plan that includes drug coverage.
On the Medigap side, the ceiling depends on the plan. A Plan G policy pays the Part A deductible and Part B coinsurance, leaving you mainly with the Part B deductible. Plans K and L have their own out-of-pocket limits, which were $8,000 and $4,000 in 2026. A high-deductible Plan G, offered in some states, required you to pay up to $2,950 in 2026 before the policy pays. Medicare.gov had not yet posted the 2027 versions of those Medigap amounts when we checked, so treat the 2026 figures as placeholders.
Running the numbers on two sample years
The premiums below are hypothetical examples, not quotes from any insurer. Real Medigap and Advantage premiums vary by ZIP code, age, carrier, and plan.
Example: Linda is looking at an Advantage plan with a $0 premium and a $5,900 in-network out-of-pocket maximum. Her alternative is Medigap Plan G at an example premium of $185 a month, or $2,220 a year, plus a stand-alone Part D plan at $40 a month, or $480 a year. On both paths she pays the Part B premium, so it cancels out of the comparison.
In a quiet year with four doctor visits and a couple of generic prescriptions, the Advantage plan might cost her $200 in copays. The Medigap path costs $2,700 in premiums plus the $283 Part B deductible, or about $2,983. The Advantage plan wins by roughly $2,800.
Now give Linda a knee replacement, a short hospital stay, and twelve weeks of physical therapy. On the Advantage plan, her copays and coinsurance could reach the $5,900 maximum. On Plan G, the policy covers the Part A deductible of $1,736 per benefit period in 2026 and her Part B coinsurance, so she still owes about $2,983 for the year. In this example, the Medigap path is about $2,900 cheaper in the bad year.
Those two results give Linda a range. The Advantage plan could save her about $2,800 or cost her about $2,900 more, depending on her health that year. If her care needs are rising, or if she would lose sleep over a $5,900 bill, that range points one way. If she is healthy and keeps a cash cushion, it may point the other way.
The parts of the bill no flyer mentions
Several costs are easy to miss on the Advantage side. A $0 premium plan still has copays for specialists, imaging, outpatient surgery, and hospital days, and those vary widely between plans. Check the plan's Evidence of Coverage, not just the summary flyer, for the cost of an MRI, a day in the hospital, and a skilled nursing stay.
Some Advantage plans also help pay part of your Part B premium, which can lower Line 1. If a plan offers that, count the actual monthly credit, not the marketing description.
On the Original Medicare side, the hidden cost is usually the Part D plan. A Medigap policy does not include prescription drug coverage for new enrollees, so you need a separate drug plan. Price it with your actual medications in Medicare's Plan Finder.
Income can also matter on both paths. People with higher incomes pay an income-related monthly adjustment amount on top of the Part B premium and Part D premium. For 2026, that extra charge started above $109,000 of modified adjusted gross income for individual filers and $218,000 for joint filers. CMS had not published the 2027 thresholds when we checked.
Dental, vision, and gym benefits: what they are worth
Original Medicare does not cover most dental care, routine eye exams, or hearing aids. Most Advantage plans offer some of these extras, which is a real draw. The 2027 Medicare and You handbook cautions that these benefits are generally limited and that you should check exactly what is covered before you join.
To value them fairly, write down what you actually spent last year on cleanings, glasses, and a gym membership. If a plan's dental benefit covers two cleanings and a small annual allowance, it may be worth a few hundred dollars to you. It is unlikely to offset a several-thousand-dollar difference in a bad year. If you are on the Original Medicare path, you can price a separate dental or vision policy and add it to Line 1 so the comparison stays apples to apples.
Networks and prior authorization: the cost of permission
Money is not the only thing that differs. With Original Medicare you can use any provider in the country that takes Medicare, which matters if you split the year between Michigan and Florida or want a specialist at a distant medical center. Advantage plans often require you to use network providers for non-emergency care, and networks can change during the year. Your plan has to tell you if a provider you see is leaving, but you generally cannot switch plans mid-year because of it.
Prior authorization is the other practical difference. Original Medicare generally does not require approval in advance for most services. Advantage plans may require it for certain services, drugs, or supplies. That does not mean care is denied, but it can add steps and delays, and you have appeal rights if a plan says no.
Before you enroll, look up every doctor and hospital you rely on in the plan's directory, then call the offices to confirm they will be in network for 2027.
The one-way door: Medigap underwriting
Here is the part that should shape your decision more than any single year's math. Your best time to buy a Medigap policy is your Medigap Open Enrollment Period, a six-month window that begins the first month you have Part B and are 65 or older. During that window, insurers generally cannot turn you down or charge more because of your health.
After that window closes, Medicare.gov warns that you may not be able to buy a Medigap policy, or it may cost more. In most states, insurers can use medical underwriting, which means health questions, higher premiums, or denial. Some states give additional rights, and federal law gives certain guaranteed issue rights in specific situations.
The trial right is one of those protections. If you drop a Medigap policy to join an Advantage plan for the first time, you have 12 months to get that policy back if the same insurer still sells it. If you joined an Advantage plan when you were first eligible at 65, you can buy certain Medigap policies if you return to Original Medicare within the first year. Outside those situations, switching from Advantage back to Original Medicare later can mean living without Medigap.
That is why Linda and Raymond, who already have Medigap, should treat switching to Advantage as a decision that may be hard to undo. Someone who is new to Medicare and healthy has more room to choose.
Timing for 2027
If you want to change plans for 2027, Open Enrollment closes December 7, 2026. If you are already in an Advantage plan and decide it was the wrong fit, the Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment Period from January 1 to March 31, 2027, lets you switch to another Advantage plan or return to Original Medicare and join a drug plan. It does not guarantee you a Medigap policy, so check your state rules and any trial rights first.
Your State Health Insurance Assistance Program offers free, unbiased counseling and can walk through the worksheet with you.
The decision
Fill in both columns with real quotes, then look hardest at the bad-year line and at whether you could buy Medigap again later. If the worst case on the Advantage plan is a number you can absorb and your doctors are in network, the lower premium can be worth it. If not, the higher monthly cost of Medigap is the price of a predictable year.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's Your Reaction?
Like
0
Dislike
0
Love
0
Funny
0
Wow
0
Sad
0
Angry
0
Comments (0)